ISC2 CC vs. CompTIA Security+: Battle of the Certifications

In the evolving landscape of cybersecurity, choosing the right certification is a pivotal decision for anyone looking to enhance their career. Whether you are at the start of your cybersecurity journey or looking to expand your expertise, the ISC2 CC and CompTIA Security+ certifications stand out as popular choices. This article dives deep into each certification, comparing their focus areas, costs, career opportunities, and overall value to help you make an informed decision.

What is ISC2 CC Certification?

The ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity certification is designed as an entry-level credential aimed at those new to the cybersecurity field. It provides foundational knowledge necessary to secure critical assets.

Target Audience and Skill Level

This certification is ideal for individuals stepping into the cybersecurity domain, offering them the basics needed to establish a solid security foundation.

Key Topics Covered

• Security Principles
• Business Continuity (BC), Disaster Recovery (DR) & Incident Response Concepts
• Access Controls Concepts
• Network Security
• Security Operations

Exam Details

• Exam Price: The ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity (CC) exam costs $199 USD.
• Duration: The exam duration is 120 minutes, providing ample time for candidates to complete the test.
• Number of Questions: Candidates will encounter 100 multiple-choice questions during the exam.
• Passing Score: A minimum score of 700 out of 1000 is required to pass the exam.

What is CompTIA Security+ Certification?

CompTIA Security+ SY0-701 is a certification that covers a broader spectrum of security topics and is designed for security professionals who are at the entry to intermediate skill level.

Target Audience and Skill Level

• It is suited for individuals looking to expand their cybersecurity knowledge across various security disciplines.

Key Topics Covered

• General Security Concepts (12%)
• Threats, Vulnerabilities, and Mitigations (22%)
• Security Architecture (18%)
• Security Operations (28%)
• Security Program Management and Oversight (20%)

Exam Details

• Exam Price: The CompTIA Security+ SY0-701 exam is priced at $404 USD.
• Duration: The exam lasts 90 minutes, requiring candidates to manage their time effectively.
• Number of Questions: The test comprises a maximum of 90 questions, including multiple-choice and performance-based formats.
• Passing Score: A score of 750 out of 900 is needed to achieve certification.

Key Differences Between ISC2 CC and CompTIA Security+

Difficulty Level

• ISC2 CC: This certification is designed with the absolute beginner in mind, focusing on the most fundamental aspects of cybersecurity. The content is structured to provide a solid groundwork in cybersecurity principles, making it ideal for those with little to no prior knowledge in the field. The exam questions are straightforward, aimed at testing understanding of basic concepts rather than the application of complex scenarios.
• CompTIA Security+: Positioned for those at the entry to intermediate level, Security+ extends beyond basic principles to include a more detailed exploration of security topics. The exam is recognized for its depth and variety, incorporating scenario-based questions that require practical application of concepts. This makes it slightly more challenging than the ISC2 CC, catering to those who may already have some experience in IT or basic security practices.

Focus Areas

• ISC2 CC: The certification emphasizes core cybersecurity skills needed to secure systems and manage threats effectively at the foundational level. It covers topics like security risk assessment, incident response, data security basics, and compliance requirements, which are essential for any cybersecurity role.
• CompTIA Security+: This certification takes a broader approach, addressing not only the fundamentals but also more complex issues such as advanced threat management, detailed cryptography, and security architecture and design. It is designed to equip professionals with the skills to apply security solutions across a variety of technologies and devices, making it suitable for roles that require diverse security knowledge.

Industry Recognition

• ISC2 CC: Although newer in the field, ISC2 CC is quickly gaining recognition due to ISC2’s established reputation in cybersecurity certification, particularly with their renowned CISSP credential. It’s especially recognized in organizations that emphasize a solid foundation of cybersecurity knowledge among their staff.
• CompTIA Security+: This certification has a long-standing reputation across a wide array of industries and is often a requisite for many IT and security roles in government and defense organizations, thanks to its comprehensive coverage of security topics. It is recognized under the DoD 8570 certification requirements, making it highly valued in U.S. federal agencies and by contractors.

Prerequisites

• ISC2 CC: One of the key advantages of the ISC2 CC is its accessibility; there are no formal prerequisites, making it an excellent choice for individuals looking to start a cybersecurity career from scratch. The certification provides an entry point into cybersecurity, with the potential to pursue more specialized or advanced certifications later.
• CompTIA Security+: CompTIA recommends that candidates for the Security+ certification have at least two years of experience in IT administration with a security focus, although it is not a mandatory prerequisite. This recommendation is based on the depth of knowledge required to successfully navigate the broader topics covered by the exam, suggesting that some hands-on experience could be beneficial.

Career Opportunities

Jobs Aligned with ISC2 CC

• Cybersecurity Analyst: This role involves monitoring and protecting organizational IT systems from cybersecurity threats and vulnerabilities. Analysts with ISC2 CC are equipped to handle entry-level tasks such as identifying, analyzing, and responding to incidents.
• IT Security Associate: Associates typically work under the guidance of more experienced security professionals, helping to implement and maintain security measures. The ISC2 CC prepares them with fundamental security knowledge necessary for supporting various security functions within an organization.
• Risk Analyst: Focused on assessing and mitigating risks to information security, risk analysts with an ISC2 CC background are well-versed in identifying potential threats and suggesting preventative measures based on their foundational cybersecurity understanding.

Jobs Aligned with CompTIA Security+

• Network Administrator: Security+ certified professionals in this role are responsible for ensuring the secure operation of computer networks. They are adept at configuring, managing, and troubleshooting network devices to maintain integrity, confidentiality, and availability of data and devices.
• Security Engineer: This advanced role involves designing and implementing security solutions to protect organizations against existing and emerging security threats. Security+ provides a broad knowledge base that is critical for developing, testing, and optimizing security systems and infrastructure.
• Systems Administrator: Often tasked with the overall maintenance, configuration, and reliable operation of computer systems; those with a Security+ certification also focus on the security aspects, applying their comprehensive understanding of security issues to manage systems effectively.

Salary Insights

• ISC2 CC: Entry-level professionals with an ISC2 CC can expect starting salaries that reflect the foundational nature of the certification but offer substantial growth potential as they gain experience and additional credentials. In markets where cybersecurity threats are increasing, ISC2 CC holders are especially valued for their specialized knowledge in cybersecurity fundamentals.
• CompTIA Security+: Professionals with a Security+ certification typically see a broader range of salary opportunities given the extensive recognition and demand for the skills covered by this certification. Salaries can vary significantly depending on the industry, role, and geographic location, with higher compensation in sectors that are particularly sensitive to security issues, such as finance and government.

ISC2 CC vs. CompTIA Security+: Cost-Benefit Analysis

Investment and Costs

• ISC2 CC: The cost of the ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity certification $199 (USD), which is relatively moderate, making it a financially accessible option for those starting their cybersecurity career. This includes the exam fee and any preparatory courses or materials. ISC2 also offers various resources that can help reduce the overall cost, such as self-study materials and community support.
• CompTIA Security+: The Cost of Security+ is $404 (USD), higher, considering the broader scope of the exam and the potentially higher costs of comprehensive study materials and training courses. However, this certification is widely recognized and required for many jobs in IT security, which can justify the higher upfront costs.

Return on Investment (ROI)

• ISC2 CC: As an entry-level certification, ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity provides a foundational credential that can significantly enhance a candidate’s employability in cybersecurity roles, setting the stage for career advancement and higher earnings as one progresses. The ROI is particularly strong when considering the certification’s role as a stepping stone to more advanced credentials and specialized roles within cybersecurity.
• CompTIA Security+: With its broad acceptance in the industry and alignment with many intermediate-level security roles, the ROI for Security+ is evident quickly. Holders of this certification can often access a wider variety of job roles and higher starting salaries compared to those without any certifications. Additionally, Security+ is often a prerequisite for more advanced certifications and specialized positions, which can lead to substantial salary increases and career growth.

Long-term Benefits

• ISC2 CC: This certification is especially beneficial in the long term for those who aim to specialize further within the cybersecurity field. The ISC2 pathway includes various advanced certifications that are well-regarded globally, offering opportunities for continued professional development and upward mobility in one’s career.
• CompTIA Security+: Security+ holders benefit from the certification’s comprehensive coverage of core security principles and practices, which are applicable across a wide range of IT jobs. The skills acquired are transferable and highly valued in various IT roles, enhancing job security and providing flexibility in career progression.

Conclusion

Choosing between ISC2 CC and CompTIA Security+ should come down to your career goals, current skill level, and the specific job roles you are targeting. Both certifications offer substantial benefits and can significantly boost your professional profile in the cybersecurity arena. Regardless of your choice, continuous learning and staying updated with the latest security practices are crucial in this dynamic field.